SOCIAL AUDIT
of
National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (NREGS)
in Behender block, Hardoi district, UP
Conducted by Asha Parivar during 29 May to 5 June 2007
(1) The common villagers are not quite aware of the NREGA. In most cases even the Gram Pradhans are not aware about the legal rights of the people under this Act.
(2) Even if the Gram Pradhan, Village Development Officer or the Panchayat Mitra are aware about the Act, they do not educate the people. For example, they do not encourage people to apply for the Job Cards or for seeking work.
JOB CARDS
(3) Most of the workers do not possess the Job Cards. They are normally with the Gram Pradhans or the Village Development Officers. Sometimes the villagers are not even aware of the fact that Job Cards exist in their names. In Village Panchayat Atuka people complained that even though they had applied for Job Cards they were not getting them. In Village Panchayat Hiya 12 villagers complained that their Job Cards were taken away from them. In Village Panchayat Bada Gaon 15 villagers have given a written complaint that inspite of asking they were not being given the Job Cards. In Village Panchayat Hiya 12 villagers gave a written complaint that their Job Cards were taken away from them.
(4) The photographs on Job Cards have been invariably affixed with people's own money even though the cost was to be borne by the government. Names of not all the adult family members desirous ofworking, especially females, have been mentioned on the Job Cards.(5) In a number of Panchayats Job Cards have been issued to only families close to the Gram Pradhan. Often these families do not require work under the NREGS. Genuine job seekers are not given Job Cards. As a result there is no official demand for work.
MUSTER ROLLS
(6) The number of days mentioned on Muster Rolls, as can be seen from detailed reports from social audits in village panchayats, are often exaggerated, siphoning off wages in the name of ignorant and unsuspecting people by putting their fake thumb impressions. Muster Rolls are hidden from the people in violation of the NREGA. Similarly, the payment of wages is not done at the work site in violation of the law.
BIAS AGAINST WOMEN AND DIFFERENTLY ABLED
(7) There is clear gender bias in allotment of work. The names of adult female members of the family desirous of doing work are not mentioned on the Job Cards nor do they get work even if they demand it.
(8) Similarly, the physically and mentally challenged individuals were also being discriminated against in allotment of work.
MINIMUM WAGES
(9) Complaints were received from workers in Village Panchayats Bidaura, Birauli, Hasanapur, Raison, Kahchari about non-payment of minimum wages. Only Rs. 50 or Rs. 55 per day were paid.
MISCELLANEOUS ISSUES
(10) According to the law the works should be chosen keeping in mind the developmental requirements and need for providing employment to the people. However, in reality, it is the people's representatives and government employees who arbitrarily decide the priorities
to suit their vested interests.
(12) The Panchayat Mitras who have been appointed to help in the implementation of the NREGS are not being assigned their task properly. Some of them have not even seen Muster Rolls. It appears that the Gram Pradhan and Village Development Officers are avoiding involving the Panchayat Mitras in the task of implementing the NREGS properly.
(13) Drinking water, shade and first aid medical facilities were missing at most of the work sites. So were the boards describing the work at site.(14) Contractors are still playing an important role in the execution of works even though the NREGA has prohibited them.
(15) In Village Panchayats Akbarpur Talhu, Atuka, Bada Gaon, Gauri Damampur, Kudauni, Raison, Samodha the elected Gram Pradhan was not performing the duty. In most cases husbands, sons, former masters or some other closely related men of Gram Pradhans were seen to be acting on behalf of the actual Pradhan.Jagdish Verma, Ram Sagar Verma, Neelkamal, Keshav Chand, Jaishankar, Ram Bharose, Bhagwandeen, Chandralekha, Suman Gautam, Rambabu, Gayadeen Bharti, Ashok Bharti, Yeshwant Rao, Virendra Singh, Karan Singh, Jitendra Dixit, Srinivas, Ram Naresh, Kamal Kishore, Vinay Kumar, Mahendra Yadav, Chunni Lal, Manoj, Ajay Patel, Usha, Mahesh, Arundhati Dhuru, Sandeep
A-893, Indira Nagar, Lucknow-226016
Ph: 0522 2347365, M: 9415022772,
e-mail: ashaashram@yahoo.com
*******
NREGS SOCIAL AUDIT – BEHENDER BLOCK OF HARDOI DISTRICT
29TH MAY TO 5TH JUNE 2007
Conducted by Asha Parivar
Report from field
1. Village Panchayat Akbarpur Talhu. The Muster Rolls for two works, link road from Pohkar’s orchard to Makka Kheda and from Babu’s house to Bahlolpur-Nasu road via Lord Shankar temple were found to be fake as these works have been performed earlier. Thus amounts spent on these works, Rs. 16,240 and Rs. 22,736, respectively, have been embezzled completely. All the Job Cards are with the Gram Pradhan. Chandra Kali Devi, the Gram Pradhan, doesn’t look after the Panchayat work herself. Gram Pradhan’s men terrified the workers so that no one was willing to speak out.
2. Village Panchayat Alawalpur. Because of lack of information not a single application for seeking work was filed by the villagers. No job cards have been made for women and disabled people. People have affixed the photographs on Job Cards at their own expense. Description boards about work, first aid medical facilities and Muster Rolls, in violation of the NREGA, were missing from the work site.
Name of work: Earth work from Sripal’s house to canal.
S.N. Name of villager No. Of actual days No. of days on Muster Roll Comments
1. Ismail s/o Basheer 11 13
2. Nabbo s/o Rakho 12 14
3. Tejpal s/o Ayodhya Prasad 7 14
4. Jameel s/o Khursheed 10 12
5. Irfan s/o Muneer 11 13
6. Husseini s/o
7. Santosh s/o Cheda 7 14
8. Asharam s/o Chabile 11 14
9. Vasudev s/o Ramautar 7 13
10. Razzak s/o Mushahib 6 14
11. Shyam Sundar s/o Chabile 7 14
12. Vikram s/o Badlu 10 13
13. Ram Krishan s/o Bhikhari 12 14
14. Beche Lal s/o Param 14 16
15. Natha s/o Badlu 10 12
16. Bhagwandin s/o Raghuwar 11 13
17. Mahmood Ali s/o Mehboob Ali 12 14
18. Rudan s/o Choti 10 13
19. Sripal s/o Bhikhari 11 14
20. Makhan s/o Subba 12 14
21. Rohan s/o Bhudhar 7 11
Name of work:
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on Muster Roll Comments
1. Vikram s/o Narpat 10 20
2. Suresh s/o Sitaram 12 19
3. Niranjan Pal s/o Mulai 16 20
4. Karimullah s/o Rahman 10 13
5. Ismail s/o Wazeer 14 19
6. Minoo s/o Roshan 15 19
7.
8. Hari Shankar s/o Makhan 12 18
9. Babu s/o Bahadur 14 20
10. Lal Mohammad s/o Raza Hassain 14 20
11. Nabbo s/o Rakho 14 18
12. Tejpal s/o Ayodhya 10 17
13. Jameel s/o Khursheed 15 17
14. Irfan s/o Muneer 12 19
15. Husseini s/o
16. Dwarika Prasad s/o Manohar 13 19
17. Santosh s/o Cheda 17 19
18. Asharam s/o Chabile 18 20
19. Vasudev s/o Ram Autar 12 18
20. Razzak s/o Mushahib 18 20
21. Babu s/o Bhabhuti 12 19
22. Shyam Sundar s/o Atar Chand 13 18
23. Vikram s/o Badlu 13 20
24. Chotkau s/o Khagga 15 17
25. Ram Kishan s/o Bhikhari 9 17
26. Beche Lal s/o Param 14 20
27. Bhagwandin s/o Raghuwar 14 17
28. Mahmood Ali s/o Mehboob Ali 13 20
29. Rudan s/o Choti 15 20
30. Sripal s/o Bhikhari 15 20
31. Makhan s/o Subba 18 20
3. Village Panchayat Asahi Azampur. People had given their photographs to the Gram Pradhan but most of them aren’t sure whether their Job Cards have been made. They have neither received the money for their photographs.
Name of works: Link road from Razzak Kheda to Pakhar Pati and link road from Razzak Kheda tri-crossing to Hasnapur.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Ram Gopal s/o Bihari 0 41 Inspite of giving his photo didn’t get JC. Thumb impression on MR even though can sign.
2. Rajaram s/o Makhan 0 41 Died in Sept. ’06 even then name shown on MR.
3. Ram Swaroop s/o Makhan 0 37 Wasn’t aware of a JC in his name.
4. Ghasite s/o Dhanna 10 39 JC with Gram Pradhan
5. Lokai s/o Dhanna 13 41 JC with Gram Pradhan
6. Ram Prasad s/o Dhanna 8 41 Son worked for 8 days. Got Rs. 50 per day.
7. Ratan Lal s/o Hemnath 0 41 Thumb impression on MR even though can sign.
8. Mansa Ram s/o Ranjeet 0 10 Wasn’t aware of JC in his name.
9. Munshilal s/o Prabhu 27 Inspite of giving Rs. 20 for the photograph didn’t get the JC.
10. Raju s/o Pritam 30 Inspite of giving his photo didn’t get JC.
11. Ram Naresh s/o Bhanu 15 Inspite of giving his photo one year ago didn’t get JC.
12. Rakesh s/o Shyam Lal 15 Doesn’t have JC.
13. Devendra s/o Bihari 30 Doesn’t have JC.
14. Shiv Prasad s/o Ramgulam 12 Doesn’t have JC.
15. Khageswar s/o Baktawar Has worked but JC has no entry.
4. Village Panchayat Atia. The workers did not have the Job Cards with them. They were with the Gram Pradhan. The villagers revealed that the only work for which Muster Rolls were made available to the social audit team was not done properly. Work shown has been construction of a road whereas in reality only repair of this road was performed.
Name of Work:
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Phool Chand 0 21
2. Ram Avtar 0 19
3. Minnu 0 19
4. Rajesh 6 19
5. Rakesh 6 18
6. Afzal 8 21
7. Pramod 2 20
8. Munna 6 21
9. Patani 2 21
10. Shri Ram 7 21
11. Ramjivan 6 19
12. Arvind Kumar 1 19
13. Shri Ram 5 20 16 years of age.
14. Sobran 7 18 17 years of age.
15. Indraprakash 6 19
16. Vishambhar 5 19 Rs. 50 per day paid as wages.
17. Ramsahay 6 19
18. Chotey 6 18
19. Ramprasad 7 19
20. Nanahake 7 19
5. Village Panchayat Atuka. The workers did not have the Job Cards with them. They were with the Gram Pradhan. The Gram Pradhan Reeta Rawat lives in
Name of work: Link road from Tikaram Khera to Chandu’s house.
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Rakesh s/o Jagrup 8 14 JC with Pradhan.
2. Guddu s/o Pyarelal 7 14 High School passed, can sign, but thumb impression shown.
3. Ramendra s/o Moolchand 8 14
4. Chota s/o Paragi 6 14
5. Pramod s/o Ramu 8 14
6. Kailash s/o Mitan 7 14
7. Balram s/o Mahavir 5 14
8. Mangu s/o Bhulai 8 14
9. Rampal s/o Chetram 6 14
10. Babu s/o Badlu 8 14
11. Rajesh s/o Raghuraj 6 14
12. Gangaram s/o Mohan 5 14 No entry on JC.
13. Niranjan s/o Ram Narayan 3 14 JC No. 60027.
Name of Work: Tree
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Gangaram s/o Bhagwati 6 7
2. Raju s/o Parsu 4 7
3. Pradeep s/o Shiv Kumar 3 7
4. Rakesh s/o Jagrup 4 7
5. Guddu s/o Pyarelal 6 7
6. Ramdas s/o Moolchand 5 7
6. Village Panchayat Bada Gaon. Instead of the work shown on MR a different work has been performed. The Gram Pradhan is Ramwati but her husband is in charge. Only 23 workers were willing to testify, remaining did not speak in front of the Gram Pradhan’s husband. When Mewa Lal s/o Ganga Prasad asked for work he was threatened. Most Job Cards have been kept by the Gram Pradhan’s husband. Genuine job seekers are not issued the Job Cards and neither given the work. 15 villagers have given a written complaint that their Job Cards are not being given to them.
Name of work: Drain desilting from Akbarpur to Jham Kheda.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Jaleel s/o Yaseen 8 17 Thumb impression on MR fake
2. Koon s/o Majeed 8 17 ,,
3. Khushi Ram s/o Lakshman 8 20 ,,
4. Chainu s/o Ghanai 8 19 ,,
5. Sundar s/o Chainu 8 18 ,,
6. Mahaveer s/o Ram Narayan 2 17 ,,
7. Prem Sagar s/o Babulal 3 19 ,,
8. Chandra Prakash s/o Raghunath 3 18 ,,
9. Jagatpal s/o Lakshman 3 19 ,,
10. Ram Khilawan s/o Jagnu 4 16 ,,
11. Jhaggu s/o Makhan 1 3 ,,
12. Beche Lal s/o Mede 2 16 ,,
13. Asharfi s/o Ram Bux 3 17 ,,
14. Munshi Lal s/o Chande 4 18 ,,
15. Sri Ram 0 19 ,,
7. Village Panchayat Bahlolpur. All the job cards were with the Gram Pradhan. It is an old work which has been shown as new.
Name of work: Earth work and brick road from Siddiquipur crossing to the door of Ram Lakhan.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Chatrapal s/o Hori Lal 4 8
2. Bhondu s/o Shivraj 5 30
3. Chailu s/o Pachcha 8 14
4. Sunil s/o Rajesh 1 4
5. Naresh s/o Ram Swaroop 5 37
6. Ayodhya s/o Keshav 0 2
7. Chandrapal s/o Prahlad 0 12
8. Awdhesh s/o Mishri 4 9
9. Girija s/o Munnilal 0 8
10. Tika Ram s/o Parsu 0 12
11. Rajesh s/o Pachcha 0 9
12. Pappu s/o Guru 0 12
13. Sushil s/o Raj Kumar 0 13
14. Suraj Pal s/o Murali 0 15
15. Ram Kishore s/o Ram Charan 0 16
16. Buddha s/o Badlu 0 16
17. Sone Lal s/o Maiku 0 13
18.
19. Munne s/o Sukhrati 10 14
20. Suresh s/o Ram Charan 20 24
21. Shailesh s/o Surya Pal 18 22
22. Kallu s/o Keshav 0 22
23. Shiv Pal s/o Ram Gopal 0 22
24. Rakesh s/o Matai 0 22
25. Santu s/o
26. Ram Khilawan s/o Hori 8 22
27. Mushtaq s/o Shera 0 22
28. Ram Shankar s/o Ram Swaroop 15 22
29. Lalta s/o Raghubir 15 22
30. Sundar Lal s/o Siya Ram 10 22
8. Village Panchayat Behender Khurd. None of the villagers possessed their Job Cards. When they ask the Gram Pradhan for it, he says that the Pradhan is supposed to keep all the job cards. The Gram Pardhan, VDO and the Panchayat Mitra have done nothing to make people aware about the NREGA. Two women and four physically challenged persons have given a written statement that even though they were interested in working they have been denied Job Cards.
Name of work: Drain desilting from Chandela to Gaurela.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on Muster Roll Comments
1. Ram Jivan s/o Bhikhari 25 28
2. Munna s/o Rajaram 10 12
3. Radhey s/o Bhikhari 4 12
4. Gangaram s/o Devi 5 7
5. Ram Autar s/o Kanhai 6 8
6. Raj Kumar s/o Shivram 9 12
7. Bhagwandin s/o Chedi 8 15
8. Kamlesh s/o Rajaram 18 28
9. Ram Bilas s/o Sriram 7 11
10. Sarvesh s/o Rajaram 6 8
11. Ram Balak s/o Bhikhari 15 27
12. Daya Shankar s/o Darshan 13 16
13.
14. Devi Gulam s/o Bishambhar 0 12
15. Bode s/o Sarju 0 12
16. Vinod s/o Rampo 0 12
17. Ramu s/o Ram Bharose 0 12
18. Bhaiyya Lal s/o Bahadur 0 12
19. Nand Kumar s/o Raghubir 0 12
20. Putani s/o Sarju 0 12
21. Putti Lal s/o Ram Autar 0 12
22. Sarvesh s/o Rajju 0 12
23. Mahesh s/o Babulal 0 12
24. Mihi Lal s/o Bhagirath 0 12
25. Sharafat s/o Suleman 10 12
26. Mahipal s/o Maiku 10 12
27. Dhurv s/o Radheylal 8 20
28. Range Lal s/o Bhagwandin 6 16
29. Shravan s/o Chanda 6 8
30. Anil s/o Narayan 3 20
31. Khushi Ram s/o Mansa Ram 15 36
32. Sripal s/o Radhey 6 20
33. Suresh s/o Ram Gulam 6 28
34. Narayan s/o Fakire 13 20
Name of work: Brick road from the door of Sarju to north going outside village.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on Muster Roll Comments
1. Shivdas s/o Chotelal 7 10
2. Narayan s/o Hiralal 0 10
3. Ramjeevan s/o Bhikhari 8 10
4. Gangaram s/o Devi 8 10
5. Ram Autar s/o Kanhai 0 10
6. Ram Sagar s/o Bhagwandin 5 10
7. Rajkumar s/o Shivram 4 10
8. Bhagwandin s/o Choti 4 10
9. Ram Bilas s/o Shriram 5 10
10. Sarvesh s/o Rajaram 8 9
11. Khalari s/o Rajaram 0 9
12. Ram Balak s/o Bhikhari 7 10
13. Bode s/o Sarju 0 10
14. Vinod s/o Rampo 0 10
15. Bhaiyya Lal s/o Bahadur 0 4
16. Nandkumar s/o Raghubir 0 9
17. Putani s/o Sarju 0 10
18. Mahesh s/o Babulal 0 10
19. Mihilal s/o Bhagirath 0 8
20. Dhruv s/o Radheylal 5 10
21. Mayaram s/o Moolchand 0 10
22. Khushi Ram s/o Mansa Ram 0 10
Name of work: Earth work and brick road from the door of Munish to the door of Shamshad.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on Muster Roll Comments
1. Shivdas s/o Chote Lal 2 4
2. Narayan s/o Hira Lal 0 4
3. Suresh s/o Devi 0 4
4. Ramjeevan s/o Bhikhari 2 4
5. Munna s/o Rajaram 2 4
6. Gangaram s/o Devi 2 4
7. Challu s/o Jagatpal 2 4
8. Ram Sagar s/o Bhagwandin 3 4
9. Ram Bilas s/o Sriram 3 4
10. Sarvesh s/o Rajaram 0 4
11. Khalari s/o Rajaram 2 4
12. Ram Balak s/o Bhikhari 2 4
13. Manoj s/o Radhey Lal 3 4
14. Daya Shankar s/o Darshan 0 4
15. Sripal s/o Radhey 2 4
16. Mayaram s/o Moolchand 0 4
17. Khushi Ram s/o Mansa Ram 0 4
18. Suresh s/o Ram Gulam 0 4
19. Narayan s/o Fakire 0 4
9. Village Panchayat Bidaura. Villagers don’t have Job Cards. The Job Cards are with the Gram Pradhan. Wage payments were made at the rate of Rs. 50 per day.
Name of work: Link road from Main road to Rudra border
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Ramdutt 8 14
2. Changa 1 14
3. Ramdulare 12 14
4. Shivshanker 3 14
5. Santosh Kumar 8 14
6. Ram Prasad 6 14
7. Sanjay 5 7
Name of work: From Main road to Virendra Door
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Shivshankar s/o Sohanlal 0 7
2. Ramdutt 3 7
3. Changa 2 7
4. Ram Dulare 3 7
5. Ramprasad 3 7
6. Deshraj 6 7
10. Village Panchayat Birauli. The labourers have got Rs. 55 per day as wages. While labourers were being interviewed the Gram Pradhan and his father started threatening the workers as a result of which a number of them could not make their statements for record. All the Job Cards were with the Gram Pradhan.
Name of work: Road from the house of Kallu Pandey to Shiv Shankar.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Sajeewan 0 36
2. Nathuni 0 36 Works as tailor.
3. Bauwa 4 36 Literate.
4. Ram Sharan 3 36
5. Nokhai 8 36
6. Ram Dayal 5 36
Name of work: Road from Sarju’s field to Ballapur border.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Sajeewan 0 28
2. Ravindra 0 28 Literate.
3. Kallu 0 28
4. Vijay Pal 0 28 Lives in
5. Baiju 15 28
6. Bal Krishna 22 28
7. Ram Kumar 20 28
8. Vishram 10 28
11. Village Panchayat Diwari.
Name of work: Desilting of drain from Kushal Khera to Gaudila Talab to Chamraha
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Ashok s/o Maiku 4 14
2. Bhahin s/o Kallu 0 14
3. Mannan s/o Moolchand 7 21
4. Kishanlal s/o Kushhar 6 14
5. Sonelal s/o Jagannath 8 14
6. Javed s/o Nanhe Hasan 7 14
7. Shravan s/o Maiku 8 14
8. Rambhajan s/o Hira 0 14
9. Bechelal s/o Lallu 0 14
10. Satnu s/o Nanhe 7 14
11. Shivkumar s/o Tulsi 4 14
12. Gangaram s/o Nanha 6 14
13. Suresh s/o Ramcharan 18 21
14. Sukhbir s/o Chandrika 10 14
12. Village Panchayat Gauri Damampur. Women are interested in working but because their names are not mentioned on the Job Cards they are not able to obtain work. No physically challenged person has got work either. The Gram Pradhan Shahrana’s son manages the village panchayat work on her behalf. His colleague Prakash Gupta has kept all the Job Cards with him and gives the work to his favourite people. Job Cards were with the Gram Pradhan. The work was being done by contractor. Attendance was taken on a register and not on MR.
S.N. Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Babu s/o Gajju 12 23
2. Naresh s/o Babu 12 16
3.
4. Santosh s/o Angne 7 8
5. Irfan s/o Mangre 5 9 Got Rs. 50 per day as wages.
6. Mangre s/o Alaraju 6 21
7. Ram Singh s/o Vishram 9 21
8. Chandra Pal s/o Dhani Ram 3 14 Can sign but thumb impression put on MR.
9. Munshi Lala s/o Barati 10 18
10. Satti Prasad s/o Dhani Ram 16 18
11. Maiku s/o Sohan Lal 12 23 Got Rs. 50 per day as wages.
12. Virendra s/o Bihari 10 16
13. Bihari s/o Badri 5 9
14. Ghurai s/o Narayan 5 26
15. Sanjay s/o
16. Uma Shankar s/o Ghurai 9 14
17. Bhagwandeen s/o Kehari 8 14
18. Rajesh Kumar s/o Shyam 9 Got only Rs. 200.
13. Village Panchayat Ghughera. The workers did not have the Job Cards with them. They were with the Gram Pradhan.
Name of work: Digging of drain from Maida Talab to Jusu Talab.
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Hemraj s/o Maiku 12 18
2. Ramesh s/o Moolchand 10 20
3.
4. Manoj Kumar s/o Bechelal 10 20
5.
6. Navi Haider s/o Shakeel Haider 0 19
7. Raji s/o Allahrakhu 0 17
8. Parwan Kumar s/o Bharose 5 20
9. Suresh Kumar s/o Babu 3 18
10. Gangacharan s/o Khagesur 0 18
11. Kallu s/o Farnand Ali 0 18
12. Jakir s/o Hajari 0 17
13. Noorul Hasan s/o Maqbul Hasan 0 21
14. Anis Haider s/o Irshad Ali 0 20
15. Shafikul Hasan s/o Taqdeer Hasan 0 19
16. Shakir Ali s/o Bakar Ali 0 18
17. Ishtekhar s/o Karam Hussain 0 17
18. Shabbu s/o Kallu 0 18
19. Nadir Ali s/o Bakar Ali 0 21
20. Salamat Hasan s/o Allahrakhu 0 20
21 Ali Rehbar s/o Munne 0 17
22. Nabir Ali s/o Bakar Ali 0 20
23. Nadir s/o Hajari 0 21
24. Rakesh s/o Chaudhi 5 17
25. Hariprasad s/o Kadhile 8 14
26. Changaram s/o Khilawan 10 20
27. Deendayal s/o Amam 5 21
28. Ramprasad s/o Khagesur 0 18
29. Suhaib Haider s/o Quaiab Haider 0 18
30. Hemraj s/o Maiku 6 18
31. Mahavir s/o Maiku 10 18
32. Shivraj s/o Ramlal 0 17
33. Gangaram s/o Sarju 7 14
34. Dayaram s/o Banne 5 18
35. Maniram s/o Nandlal 0 12
36. Naresh s/o Moti 0 15
37. Ramcharan s/o Badlu 0 15
38. Ramkumar s/o Gayadeen 0 16
39. Banwarilal s/o Shivdeen 0 14
40. Ishrat Ali s/o Karam Hasan 0 19
41. Mauji s/o Deendayal 2 5
42. Harinam s/o Mihilal 1 3
43. Baldev s/o Ramprasad 0 4
Name of work: Drain desilting from Dubka Talab to Rithwe.
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Ramesh s/o Moolchand 4 21
2.
3. Mansingh s/o Gangaram 6 22
4. Sunderlal s/o Bhagwandin 6 22
5. Lakshman s/o Mulla 17 21
6. Manoj s/o Bechelal 10 23
7. Mahender s/o Ramkishore 8 22
8. Ramlal s/o Maiku 10 23
9. Shri Ram s/o Cheda 0 21
10. Salman s/o Allahrakhu 0 23
11.
12. Anis s/o Irshad 0 23
13. Shakir Ali s/o Bakar Ali 0 21
14. Nadir s/o Bakar Ali 0 22
15. Istekhar s/o Karam Hasan 0 22
16. Ishrat Ali s/o Karam Hasan 0 22
17. Nandlal s/o Sarju 10 22
18. Nabir s/o Bakar Ali 0 23
19. Shabbu s/o Kallu 0 23
20. Jiohaider s/o Shafiq Hasan 0 21
21. Nankaunu s/o Bhima 8 22
22. Bechelal s/o Nankaunu 4 23
23. Kishan s/o Hajari 10 22
24. Hari s/o Bhagga 0 22
25. Ramvilas s/o Bhagga 0 21
26 Ramswarup s/o Chandrika 10 22
27. Babu s/o Chandrika 9 22
28. Thakur Prasad s/o Kalika 7 22
29. Vijay Kumar s/o Bhagwati 12 23
30. Vishveshwar s/o Ram Bharose 16 21
Name of work: Tree
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Chatarpal s/o Nanha 22 28
2. Pappu s/o Shyamlal 7 30
3. Shakir Hasan s/o Taqdeer Hasan 0 28
4. Anis Haider s/o Irshad Ali 0 30
5. Nurul Hasan s/o Maqbool Hasan 0 30
6. Ishrat Ali s/o Karam Hussain 0 28
7. Shakir s/o Hajari 0 27
8. Kallu s/o Harjung 0 29
9. Jagdish s/o Bhagga 0 28
10. Alok s/o Gokul 0 28
11. Hemraj s/o Maiku 12 29
14. Village Panchayat Ghuspahan. All the Job Cards were with the Gram Pradhan. The thumb impressions and signatures on MR are all fake.
Name of work: Brick road ahead from Prabhu Pasi’s door.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Ram Lotan s/o Meharban 16 24
2. Ram Das s/o Ramai 15 24
3. Munna s/o Parmeshwar 14 24
4. Khushi Ram s/o Gulzari 13 24
5. Udan s/o Fakire 11 24
6. Chanderpal s/o Jairam 10 24
7. Parmai s/o Jhinguri 9 24
8. Gopal s/o Puran 8 24
9. Muninder s/o Shobhran 7 24
10. Shobhran s/o Lekhan 23 24
11. Ram Kumar s/o Ram Prasad 23 24
12. Ram Pal s/o Darshan 23 24
13. Putan s/o Parmeshwar 16 24
14. Rajesh s/o Putti Lal 23 24
15. Vinod s/o Ram Pal 5 24
16. Asharfi s/o Bhudhar 16 24
17. Purushottam s/o Bulari 23 24
18. Chote Lal s/o Dhana 23 24
19. Shivnandan s/o Gauri 0 24
20. Kallu s/o Shankar 23 24
21. Ashok s/o Ram Gulam 16 24
22. Pyare s/o Dhana 23 24
23. Ramesh s/o Bhikha 23 24
24. Balak s/o Kallu 23 24
25. Ram Khilawan s/o Jairam 23 24
26. Mithilesh s/o Shyam Bahadur 0 24
27. Snehi s/o Shyam Lal 0 24
28. Sheetla s/o Khemman 16 24
29. Naresh s/o Kallu 15 17
30. Mohan s/o Bele 15 17
Name of work: Tree plantation.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Shukla s/o Shiv Ratan 0 11
2. Mohan s/o Bele 10 11
3. Vimlesh s/o Shyam Bahadur 0 11
4. Snehi s/o Shyam Lal 0 11
5. Ram Singh s/o Jairam 5 11
6. Shobhran s/o Lekhan 10 11
7. Muninder s/o Shobhran 9 10
8. Gopal s/o Puran 5 10
9. Khushi Ram s/o Gulzari 9 10
10. Ram Das s/o Ramai 9 10
11. Bele s/o Shankar 9 10
15. Village Panchayat Hasanapur. The Panchayat Mitra, whose job it is to help with the NREGS work, has been kept out of the scheme. The Job Cards were distributed just a day before the social audit team visited the village. The issue date of one of the Job Cards has been mentioned as 26/4/05. In this Village Panchayat Ram Autar s/o Gajraj has been issued a blank Job Card. The workers have been made payment at the rate of Rs. 50 per day.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Mahipal s/o Mitan 13 27
2. Chandrika s/o Hori Lal 9 27 Has not signed or put thumb impression on MR.
3. Angne s/o Gulab 5 27 ,,
4. Rajkumar s/o Kadhile 10 27
5. Kamta s/o Sundar Lal 7 27
6. Sumit s/o Putti Lal 10 27
7. Santu s/o Lalta 5 27
8. Ram Chandar s/o Angne 5 27 JC issued on 26/4/05.
9. Kamal Kumar s/o Sundar 7 27 Work was performed by brother Raju.
10. Ramu s/o Khanjan 5 27 Fake thumb impression on MR.
11. Bhagga s/o Munna 13 27
16. Village Panchayat Hiya. The workers did not have the Job Cards with them. They were with the Gram Pradhan Mallan Devi. When the social audit team was interviewing the workers, the fair price shop owner Krishna Kumar and a contractor, acting on behalf of the Gram Pradhan, abused the workers and threatened them for speaking out the truth. Nanhe Lal complained that one day when he arrived 15 minutes late on work site he was asked to go back. Dilawar s/o
Name of work: Road from Karaundi Khera to Jariyari.
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Sonelal s/o Guddu 0 20
2. Ramesh s/o Chotelal 0 22
3. Pappu s/o Chotelal 16 25
4. Gayaprasad s/o Munna 0 22
5. Chotelal s/o Sukuru 0 26
6. Munna s/o Gajju 0 18
7. Hannu s/o Gajju 0 21
8. Ramsagar s/o Gajju 0 20
9. Shyamlal s/o Ramdin 0 25
10. Shri Kishan s/o Budhai 0 23
11. Shiv Prasad s/o Shivlal 0 24
12. Badlu s/o Shyamlal 0 24
13. Thakuri s/o Pohkar 0 25
14. Rajender s/o Shyamlal 0 26
15. Makrand s/o Narpati 10 25
16. Shrupal s/o Siyaram 0 26
Name of work: Brick road from Lakshman Chaupal’s to Jodi Chaupal’s.
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Kamta Prasad s/o Lekhai 0 5
2. Makrand s/o Narpati 0 6
3. Birendra s/o Mangali 0 5
4. Shyam s/o Ramdin 0 5
5.
6. Rasali s/o Minna 0 6
7.
8. Ramesh s/o Ramdayal 0 5
9. Thakuri s/o Badlu 0 7
Name of work: Link road from Rajesh’s house to Subba Khera.
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Rajpal s/o Ghaseete 0 10
2. Dilawar s/o
3. Nanhelal s/o Durjan 0 10
4. Kanhaiya s/o Mulla 0 11
5. Shri Pal s/o Ramlal 0 9
6. Rajesh s/o Subedar 0 10
7. Majnu s/o Ramlal 0 11
8. Laiku s/o Gajodhar 0 12
Name of work: Link road repaired from Shivpal’s field to Karaundi Khera.
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Shri Pal s/o Reoti 0 31
2. Gajnu s/o Ramlal 0 28
3. Rampal s/o Ghaseete 0 29
4. Prabhu s/o Ghaseete 10 25
5. Phoolchand s/o Ghaseete 0 28
6. Kanhaiya s/o Mulla 22 29
7. Ramesh s/o Ramlal 15 32
8. Shri Pal s/o Ramlal 22 27
9. Rajesh s/o Subedar 13 29
10. Ramesh s/o Baldev 25 32
11. Ramswaroop s/o Reoti 18 29
12. Ramlotan s/o Moolchand 0 33
13. Rasali s/o Minna 3 32
14. Abbas s/o Minna 8 25
15. Ahmed Ali s/o Maula 0 29
16. Rishi s/o Maiku 14 27
17. Jagdish s/o Baiju 0 29
18. Kamta s/o Lekhai 10 29
19. Ramavtar s/o Gokul 0 30
20. Ghurai s/o Bhudhar 3 23
Name of work: Link road from Shankar’s house to the river.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual day No. of days on MR Comments
1. Virendra Kumar 0 27
2. Raghubir 0 27
3. Vinod Kumar 8 26 JC shows 19 days of work.
4. Balram 9 27 JC shows 20 days of work.
5. Harikaran 3 27
6. Ram Lal 11 27 Rs. 400 remains to be paid.
7. Mihi Lal 10 26
8. Kamlesh 10 27
9. Suresh 10 27
10. Ramu 10 26
11. Raghubir 11 27
12. Bhagirath 8 27
13. Basant Lal 11 22
14. Ram Khilawan 6 27
15. Ramesh 6 27
18. Village Panchayat Jaraha. About 20 villagers who are outsiders, have migrated to cities or are between 65 and 75 years of age were shown to have performed work on Muster Rolls. People were not informed by the Gram Pradhan of VDO that they have to formally ask for work.
Name of work: Earthwork and brick road from Prabhu’s house to Sriram’s house.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on Muster Roll Comments
1. Ram Kumar s/o Maddar 10 14
2. Kallu s/o Nanhu 5 14
3. Hari s/o Chotai 6 14
4. Sadhari s/o Angnu 10 12
5. Sripal s/o Jagnu 10 14
6. Bhaiyya Lal s/o Churai 8 14
7. Nokhe s/o Bhagwati 9 13
8. Kallu s/o Sadhari 8 14
9. Chetram s/o Natha 6 13
10. Deshraj s/o Ramdeen 5 14
11. Puran s/o
12. Sundar Lal s/o Gangadhar 8 14
13. Putti Lal s/o Nanha 7 13
14. Jawahar s/o Bhabhuti 6 14
15. Jilal s/o Bhabhuti 6 13
16. Surji s/o Nanha 7 13
17. Bhoop s/o Bhabhuti 7 13
18. Moolchand s/o Mahaveer 6 13
19. Bablu s/o Motilal 6 13
20. Ramcharan s/o Baldev 0 13 80 years of age.
21. Jahur s/o Bahadur 0 12 Works outside as a driver.
Name of work: Earth work and brick road from behind Junior High School to Dr. Vijay Maurya’s house.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on Muster Roll Comments
1. Sadhari s/o Angnu 6 16
2. Bhaiyya Lal s/o Churai 8 14
3. Kallu s/o Sadhari 10 14
4. Deshraj s/o Ramdin 10 14
5. Puran s/o
6. Jilal s/o Bhabhuti 6 14
7. Murali s/o Devidas 6 9
8. Mewa Lal s/o Lallu 0 10 Well off family.
9. Ram Swaroop s/o Maiku 0 5 Works at a brick kiln.
10. Kamlesh s/o Shivlal 0 16 Works in a factory.
11. Mukaddar s/o Bagulibaaj 0 19 Doesn’t live in village. Roams around.
12. Raju s/o Maiku 0 10 Works at a brick kiln.
Name of work: Earth work from Raghuwar’s field to Matru’s field.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on Muster Roll Comments
1. Ram Kumar s/o Maddar 10 14
2. Kallu s/o Nanhu 6 13
3. Sripal s/o Jagnu 5 17
4. Bhaiyya Lal s/o Churai 10 13
5. Nokhe s/o Bhagwati 9 13
6. Chetram s/o Natha 6 13
7. Putti Lal s/o Nanha 6 9
8. Jawahar s/o Bhabhuti 7 13
9. Bhoop s/o Bhabhuti 7 14
10. Moolchand s/o Mahaveer 7 13
11. Bablu s/o Motilal 10 14
12. Chote s/o Girija Shankar 0 14
13. Ram Kumar s/o Mishri Lal 0 13
14. Raj Kishore s/o Ram Swaroop 0 13
15. Baburam s/o Gurudeen 0 12 Possesses 10 bighas of land, tractor, motorcycle
16. Dhyan Das s/o Rampal 10 14
17. Mahendra Singh s/o Mardan Singh 0 14
18. Uday Pratap Singh s/o Bachan Singh 0 13 Cousin of Gram Pradhan
19. Ram Kishan s/o Devideen 0 14 Works as carpenter in Mumbai
20. Shiv Charan s/o Sundar Singh 0 11 Possesses land, gun, motorcycle
21. Sageer s/o Bagulibaaj 0 11 Doesn’t normally live in village
22. Jaleel s/o Bagulibaaj 0 11 ,,
23. Anees s/o Bagulibaaj 0 10 ,,
24. Gurucharan s/o Sukha 0 10 Works at a brick kiln.
19. Village Panchayat Kahchari. All labourers received only Rs. 50 per day as wages. In this village the maximum number of work given to any labourer is for 7 days as against the guarantee of 100 days in the year. Only 8 villagers out of 150 who have been issued Job Cards have got work for 55 person days only. As a result the average work given to a worker in this panchayat during the year is 0.3. The Job Cards have been issued to only people who are close to the Gram Pradhan, most of whom do not need work under NREGS. Hence there is no demand for work. Genuine job seekers have been denied Job Cards.
Name of work: Soling lying from Lalta’s house to Chatrapal’s house.
S.N. Name of villager No. Of actual days No. Of days on MR Comments
1. Balak s/o Mulla 7 7 Received on Rs. 50 per day as wages.
2. Tulsi Ram s/o Cheda 7 7 ,,
3. Shiv Ratan s/o Moti 7 7 ,,
4. Suraj Pal s/o Prakash 7 7 ,,
5. Kanhaiya Lal s/o Kalika 7 7 ,,
6. Rajneesh s/o Ram Sewak 7 7 ,,
7. Ram Gulam s/o Moti 7 7 ,,
8. Mulhe s/o Durjan 6 6 ,,
20. Village Panchayat Kakendua. All thumb impressions and signatures on muster roll are fake. Job Cards were with the Gram Pradhan. Not a single woman’s name listed on the Muster Rolls. Muster Rolls contain names of close relatives of Gram Pradhan who have not worked themselves in reality. Genuine job seekers have not been given Job Cards or work.
Name of work: Drain desilting from Chapuruwa to Harchala.
S.N. Name of villager No. Of actual days No. Of days on MR Comments
1. Ram Khilawan s/o Dullan 17 21
2. Jagdish s/o Jagan 8 14
3. Bharose s/o Dagru 11 12
4. Naresh s/o Nokhe 12 14
5. Bhailal s/o Chhotelal 14 21
6. Putti Lal s/o Prasad 11 14
7. Chhanga s/o Kheman 9 14
8.
9. Rakesh s/o Ram Autar 7 10
10. Jiyalal s/o Bhikhari 9 14
11. Gauri Shankar s/o Vijay Pal 7 21
12. Lekhai s/o Nanhu 17 21
13. Jagan Narayan s/o Chhotta 17 21
14. Rakesh s/o Kanhaiya Lal 15 28
15. Lal Bihari s/o Parmeshwar 17 21
16. Raju s/o Rachla 17 21
17. Ekbal s/o Amzad 21 28
18. Shyamu s/o Nattha 15 21
19. Nand Kishore s/o Nattha 20 21
20. Siyaram s/o Dullu 12 21
21. Raj Kumar s/o Balak 13 28
22. Hori s/o Prasad 13 20
23. Jodhi s/o Parmeshwar 13 21
24. Khusi Ram s/o Hirai 13 28
25. Ramesh s/o Ballar 5 7
26. Bablu s/o Shyamu 5 7
27. Kallu s/o Ratan 5 7
Name of work: Earth work from Canal to Diwan Khera.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Balak s/o Jhodha 0 17
2. Hira lal s/o Prasad 0 17
3. Nand Kishore s/o Nattha 14 17
4. Lalta s/o Teja 7 17
5. Shilu s/o Pappu 0 25
6. Pappu s/o Jagdish 0 24
7. Munne s/o Dulle 0 24
8. Irfan Ali s/o Sirdar 0 24
9. Nafis Ali s/o Nakhat 0 24
Name of work: Brick road and earth work from Jamalu’s house to the road going east.
S.N. Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Shilu s/o Pappu 0 10
2. Angnu s/o Nanhu 0 10
21. Village Panchayat Karlawan. The workers did not have the Job Cards with them. They were with the Gram Pradhan. Only one woman was given employment at a work site to provide drinking water to the remaining workers.
Name of works: Drain digging work from Rohi pond to Bada pond and earth work and brick road from Haji’s house to Jiman Kheda.
S.N. Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Raju s/o Shyam Lal 28 29
2. Gulzari s/o Kallu 15 51
3. Gangaram s/o Devi Prasad 28 29
4. Hanif s/o Sukhdeo 28 30
5.
6. Manmohan s/o Kallu 20 32
7. Makka s/o Sewa 20 21
8. Dipu s/o Girija Shankar 30 31
9. Gende Lal s/o Mohan 20 45
10. Mushtaq Ali s/o Abdul 20 21
11. Ghasi Ram s/o Bal Kishan 20 21
12. Ambar Pal s/o Dan Chand 20 33
13. Hemnath s/o Hira 20 33
14. Puttilal s/o Kallu 20 21
15. Naresh s/o Balak 20 34
16. Rambux s/o Baiju 20 34
17. Saroj s/o Ram Karan 20 23
18. Shayam Lal s/o Maiku 20 22
19. Kamlesh s/o Hira Lal 20 21
20. Sunder s/o
21. Girjashankar s/o Chandrika 20 21
22. Bhagwandin s/o Dwarika 20 21
23. Munish s/o Subedar 20 38
24. Mangu s/o Kallu 20 26
25. Budha s/o Chotle Lal 20 28
26. Mahavir s/o Pachcha 15 51
27. Inderpal s/o Sohan 20 39
28. Radheylal s/o Kallu 20 49
29. Shivram s/o Fakire 10 11
30. Manohar s/o Lakshman 10 11
31. Shivratan 10 11
22. Village Panchayat Kharika.
Name of work: Link road from Rajepal’s house to Nabiapur.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Munnilal s/o Udil 0 14
2. Bodhlal s/o
3. Raj Kumar s/o Kallu 0 14
4. Manna Lal s/o Lalla 0 14
5. Kallu s/o Zalim 0 14
6. Shailendra s/o Shyam Lal 12 14
7. Rakesh s/o Lalta 12 14
8. Mangu s/o Jodhi 0 14
9. Ashok s/o Pancham 0 14
10. Jagroop s/o Ramnath 0 14
11. Deshraj s/o Sitaram 0 14
12. Manohar s/o Ram Swaroop 13 14
13. Vijay Pal s/o Sri Ram 0 14
14. Ram Kumar s/o Guru Sahai 0 14
15. Ram Asre s/o
16. Khushi Ram s/o Ram Swaroop 0 14
17. Ram Balak s/o Bhagwati 0 14
18. Chedi Lal s/o Vishwanath 13 14
19. Raj Kumar s/o Guru Sahai 0 14
20. Bhagwandeen s/o Madari 0 14
21. Balak Ram s/o Nanda 0 14
22. Premchand s/o Raghuwar 0 14
23. Sanjay s/o Khemal 0 14
24.
25. Ram Pal s/o Shiv Ram 0 14
26.
27. Chote Lal s/o Chetram 0 14
28. Sujit Kumar s/o Devi Gulam 0 14
29. Bramha s/o Chote Lal 0 14
30. Babu s/o Badlu 0 14
31. Matole s/o Babu 0 14
32. Jairam s/o Kadhile 0 14
33. Rajesh s/o Pancham 0 14
34. Chote Lal s/o Mangu 0 14
35. Ranghunandan s/o Sukhlal 12 14
36. Vimal Kumar s/o Gajodhar 0 14
37. Shravan s/o Hari 0 14
38. Uma Shankar s/o Ram Sahai 0 14
Name of work: Link road from Hiya road to Jariyari.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Sant Ram s/o Ram Dayal 12 14
2. Chandra Pal s/o Natha 0 14
3. Ram Khilwan s/o Chotu 0 14
4. Kamta s/o Kewal 12 14
5. Dulam s/o Natha 0 14
6. Nanhakke s/o Moolchand 0 14
7. Roop Chand s/o Bhagwati 0 14
8. Ram Nath s/o Sita Ram 0 14
9. Rajesh s/o Ram Swaroop 0 14
10. Amar Pal s/o Rajaram 0 14
11. Dashrath s/o Lala 0 14
12. Maheshwar Prasad s/o Vishram 0 14
13. Jagjeevan s/o Ram Nath 0 14
14. Rajendra s/o Lalta Prasad 0 14
15. Vishram s/o Sita Ram 0 14
16. Mansoor s/o Gani Ahmad 13 14
Name of work: Link road from Hiya main road to Jariyari.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Mangu s/o Hazari 0 25
2. Ramesh s/o Kishan 0 26
3. Ram Sewak s/o Dubari 0 26
4. Shivraj s/o Maiku 0 26
5. Siya Ram s/o Nanhakke 0 26
6. Sirdar s/o Hazari 0 26
7. Chote Lal s/o Sukhru 0 25
8. Rakesh s/o Ram Sewak 0 27
9. Ram Pal s/o Rupan 0 26
10. Gajodhar s/o Sripal 0 26
11. Chandrika s/o Angnu 0 26
12. Izahar s/o Mangu 0 25
13. Santosh s/o Ram Sahai 0 27
14. Beche Lal s/o Subedar 0 26
15. Bhullu s/o Sukhru 0 27
16. Babu s/o Gobare 0 27
17. Dayaram s/o Sriram 0 26
18. Ram Kishore s/o Kedar 0 25
Name of work: Brick road from the house of Suresh to house of Raheem.S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Shiv Raj s/o Maiku 0 8
2. Ram Kishore s/o Hazari 5 8
3. Daya Ram s/o Sri Ram 0 8
4. Santosh s/o Ram Sahai 0 8
5. Izahar s/o Mangu 0 8
Name of work: Brick road from the house of Moti to house of Raghunandan.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Uma Shankar s/o Bhola 0 7
2. Chote Lal s/o Mangu 0 6
3. Hemraj s/o Mangu 0 6
4. Makarand s/o Chaudhary 0 6
5. Dulam s/o Parasu 0 6
6. Mishri Lal s/o Mulla 0 6
7. Mihi Lal s/o Chauhary 0 7
Name of work: Brick road from Arjun’s house to the north of village.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Vishram s/o Sita Ram 0 7
2. Subhash s/o Lalchand 0 6
3. Rupendra s/o Bhagwati 0 7
4. Ram Nath s/o Sita Ram 0 7
5. Ram Balak s/o Bhagwati 0 7
6. Kishori Nanda s/o Bhagwati 0 7
7. Khushi Ram s/o Ram Swaroop 0 7
8. Chote Lal s/o Chetram 0 7
9. Ram Pal s/o Shiv Ram 0 6
10.
11. Kallu s/o Zalim 0 6
12. Shailendra s/o Shyam Lal 0 6
Name of work: Link road from Chamrahia to Godwa Bhoop.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Surendra s/o Hazari 0 14
2. Heera Lal s/o Prasadi 0 14
3. Kamlesh s/o Prasadi 0 14
4. Ram Kumar s/o Kallu 0 14
5. Shiv Kailash s/o Bhola 0 14
6. Chandar s/o Hulasi 0 7
7. Ram Prakash s/o Khanna 0 14
8. Chandrika s/o Minna 0 14
9. Tika Ram s/o Bedil 0 14
10. Arbi s/o Hazari 7 14
Name of work: Link road from Wazirabad to Alahar.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Jaipal s/o Gayari 0 14
2. Ram Kumar s/o Illa 0 14
3. Gajraj s/o Pancham 0 14
4. Kishan s/o Munnilal 0 14
5. Madari s/o Kadhile 13 14
6. Amarpal s/o Rajaram 0 14
7. Arabi s/o Hazari 0 13
23. Village Panchayat Kudauni. All thumb impressions and signatures on muster roll are fake. The Job Cards are with the Gram Pradhan. Gram Pradhan Ganga Dei’s husband Gaya Prasad, who runs the show here, revealed that because of dispute over sharing of ‘commission,’ the VDO and other officials were not preparing the work estimates. The present and the immediate past Gram Pradhans have been from village Hussainpur, hence the development works in Kudauni village have been neglected.
Name of work: Drain digging from Palia bridge.
S.N. Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Moolchand s/o Mohan Lal 20 24
2. Sukh Lal s/o Kalika 20 24
3. Jilal s/o Nanha 20 24
4. Ram Swaroop s/o Nanha 18 22
5. Ram Swaroop s/o Shivram 21 23
6. Chotai s/o Mathuri 20 24
7. Mangu s/o Hirai 18 24
8. Munna s/o Mathrui 20 22
9. Rakesh s/o Ram Autar 19 22
10. Kallu s/o Kalika 20 21
11. Rajendra s/o Fakire 20 22
12. Jagrup s/o Maiku 21 23
24. Village Panchayat Madar. Muster Roll is filled not at the work site but later by the Pradhan of the Village Development Officer. The entries of MR, JC and actual testimony of workers are all different from each other. In the drain desilting work only grass was removed superficially. Most of the villagers were not willing to speak out because of the fear of Gram Pradhan.
Name of work: Drain desilting from Usraila pond to Madar culvert and link road from habitation to Baiju’s field.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Rohan 4 13
2. Rajkumar 12 24
3. Ashok 11 16
4. Surendra 5 13
5. Sri Ram 9 16
6. Ram Pal 5 11
25. Village Panchayat Pilakhni.
Name of work: Link road from Asahi road to Pancham Khera.
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Ashok s/o Jairam 10 14
2. Jaipal s/o Gulzari 6 14
3. Putai s/o Mehmood 0 14
4. Ramdas s/o Lallu 0 14
5. Radheylal s/o Lakshman 0 14
6. Chotte s/o Jagannath 0 14
7. Moolchand s/o Lokai 0 14
8. Mahesh s/o Bhogai 0 14
9. Ashok s/o Shanker 7 14
10. Ahibaran s/o Bhabhuti 8 14
11. Dubar s/o Kallu 12 14
12. Jeje s/o Horilal 4 14
13. Ramchandra s/o Nandlal 4 14
14. Daulat s/o Radhey 0 14
Name of work: Brick road between main passage to Natha’s House.
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Bateshwar s/o Nandu 0 7
2. Vinod s/o Ramprasad 0 7
3. Brijlal s/o Rambaksh 0 6
4. Ramcharan s/o Pohkar 0 6
Name of work: Brick road from Asahi road to Chotte Maurya
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Shivpal s/o Sukhe 0 3
2. Jodhi s/o Baksh 0 3
3. Suresh s/o Pohkar 0 3
Name of work: Link road from Padari to Asahi road.
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Suraj s/o Saharey 0 14
2. Rajkumar s/o Bhupat 0 14
3. Pappu s/o Nandlal 0 14
4. Chander s/o Babu 0 14
5. Kadhile s/o Mahadev 0 14
6. Prakash s/o Tilak 0 14
7. Ramsewak s/o Puttilal 0 14
Name of work: Link road from Asahi road to Govind Khera.
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Raju s/o Shivprasad 0 8
2. Jagnu s/o Bhup 0 8
3. Rajesh s/o Kudari 0 8
4. Kamlesh s/o Shivram 0 8
5. Khushiram s/o Kishori 0 8
6. Ramsagar s/o Kundali 0 8
26. Village Panchayat Raison. The Gram Pradhan, Mulla Maurya, is not in control of the Panchayat which is actually controlled by his employer former Pradhan Kiran Gupta. The wages were paid only at the rate of Rs. 50 per day. The workers have affixed the photographs on the Job Cards at their own expense. Names of women are not mentioned on the Job Cards. In a pond digging work two supervisors were appointed for 15 workers. Some children were also found to be working. There are no boards with description at work sites.
Name of work:
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on Muster Roll Comments
1. Tejpal s/o Jurakhan 0 13
2. Ramesh s/o Bechan 0 7
3. Shishu Pal s/o Hari Ram 0 16
4. Mahendra s/o Sripal 0 9
5. Chote Lal s/o Bechan 0 7
6. Chote Lal s/o Bhagwandin 0 16
7. Sher Singh s/o Bhagwandin 0 7
8. Satti Ram s/o Sita Ram 0 9
9. Bablu s/o Lalta 0 9
10. Ramdeen s/o Sripal 0 10
11. Kiran s/o Bechan 0 7
12. Rajendra s/o Jurakhan 0 7
13. Ashok s/o Ram Sewak 0 13
14. Nanhakke s/o Bechan 0 16
15. Vijay s/o Jurakhan 0 16
16. Gangaram s/o Diggaj 0 8
17. Jagdish s/o Tote 0 9
18. Shankar Lal s/o Gajodhar 0 7
19. Panchu Lal s/o Lalta 0 16
20. Chandra Gupta s/o Shyam Manohar 0 9
21. Babu s/o Deva 3 9
22. Manoj s/o Gulli 0 9
23. Chandrika s/o Lekhan 0 9
24. Rakesh s/o Gokaran 0 8
Name of work: Link road from Chetai’s field to Thakur Prasad’s field.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on Muster Roll Comments
1. Ramdeen s/o Sripal 25 31
2. Radhey s/o Bechan 20 31
3. Kiran s/o Bechan 0 31
4. Jairam s/o Mangu 8 31
5. Anand Kumar s/o Ram Swaroop 6 31
6. Mahesh s/o Ram Bilas 18 31
7. Ashok s/o Ram Sewak 25 31
8. Nanhakke s/o Bechan 28 31
9. Vijay s/o Jorakhan 18 31
10. Chetram s/o Makka 25 31
11. Jagdish s/o Tote 21 31
12. Sushil s/o Rupan 8 31
13. Tejpal s/o Jorakhan 15 31
14. Ram Naresh s/o Madhai 20 31
15. Ramesh s/o Bechan 15 31
16. Shishupal s/o Bechan 8 31
17. Mahendra s/o Sripal 25 31
18. Raju s/o Panchu 25 31
19. Chote Lal s/o Bechan 25 31
20. Dilip s/o Ram Sewak 25 31
21. Chote Lal s/o Ramdeen 15 31
22. Sher Singh s/o Bhagwandin 25 31
23. Panchu s/o Lalta 20 31
24. Bablu s/o Lalta 22 31
Name of work: Road from the field of Om Prakash Deewan to the house of Mansa.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on Muster Roll Comments
1. Tejpal s/o Jorakhan 0 16
2. Ram Naresh s/o Madhai 0 7
3. Ramesh s/o Bechan 0 7
4. Shishu Pal s/o Hari Ram 0 7
5. Mahendra s/o Sripal 0 7
6. Raju s/o Panchu 0 7
7. Chote Lal s/o Bhagwandeen 0 16
8. Ram Charan s/o Bechan 0 16
9. Panchu s/o Lalta 0 16
10. Bablu s/o Lalta 0 7
11. Ramdeen s/o Sripal 0 7
12. Kiran s/o Bechan 0 16
13. Rajendra s/o Jorakhan 0 6
14. Jairam s/o Mangu 0 5
15. Keshav s/o Lalta 0 7
16. Mahesh s/o Ram Bilas 0 7
17. Ashok s/o Ram Sewak 0 16
18. Nanhakke s/o Bechan 0 15
19. Vijay s/o Jorakhan 0 16
20. Cheta Ram s/o Makka 0 14
21. Jagdish s/o Tote 0 7
22. Anil s/o Rupan 0 15
23. Shankar s/o Gajodhar 0 7
24. Radhey s/o Bechan 0 7
Name of work: Link road from Lalta Pasi’s field to the house of Sundar Pasi.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on Muster Roll Comments
1. Tejpal s/o Jorakhan 5 33
2. Ram Naresh s/o Madhai 8 26
3. Ramesh s/o Bechan 20 33
4. Shishu Pal s/o Hari Ram 25 35
5. Chote Lal s/o Bechan 25 31
6. Dilip s/o Ram Sewak 20 33
7. Chote Lal s/o Bhagwandeen 20 33
8. Sher Singh s/o Bhagwandeen 25 31
9. Ram Charan s/o Bechan 22 33
10. Panchan s/o Lalta 22 33
11. Ramdeen s/o Sripal 20 33
12. Radhey s/o Bechan 20 33
13. Rajendra s/o Jorakhan 22 33
14. Jairam s/o Mangu 0 33
15. Anant Kumar s/o Ram Swaroop 0 7
16. Keshav s/o Lalta 10 33
17. Mahesh s/o Ram Bilas 12 26
18. Ashok s/o Ram Sewak 23 33
19. Nanhakke s/o Bechan 18 33
20. Vijay s/o Jorakhan 15 33
21. Chetram s/o Makka 0 14
22. Jagdish s/o Tote 0 7
23. Shankar Lal s/o Gajodhar 15 33
27. Village Panchayat Rasulpur Aant. None of the provisions of NREGA are being followed neither do the villagers have much knowledge about the scheme. Some of the Job Cards were with the Gram Pradhan.
Name of works: Desilting of drain from Kudia pond to Mehndi pond, link road from Ram Singh’s field to Ram Sahai’s field, link road from Shubhan Kheda to Haroon’s field and drain and brick work from Ibabul’s house to Musharrat’s house.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on Muster Roll Comments
1. Munshi Lal s/o Lachcha 13 36
2. Mahaveer s/o Lachcha 18 43
3. Keshav s/o Lachcha 0 21
4. Toteram s/o Jodhe 1 17
5. Uday Chand s/o Jeje 5 22
6. Raj Kumar s/o Chetram 16 21
7. Jagdish s/o Gayari 32 42
8. Rajkumar s/o Puran 1 21
9. Kallu s/o Bhopai 4 28
10. Ram Charan s/o Jilla 2 28
11. Ramu s/o Munni Lal 15 35
12. Ram Kumar s/o Shimma 18 35
13. Chandra Pal s/o Rupan 15 35
14. Pappu s/o Bhagwandeen 0 14
28. Village Panchayat Rasulpur Bamhnan. The workers did not have the Job Cards with them. They were with the Gram Pradhan. Fake Muster Rolls have been fabricated. The bricks used in road from Gopali’s house to Mahavir’s house are used ones whereas 18,000 new bricks purchased for Rs. 37,500 have been shown. This brick road has merely been repaired.
Name of work: Earth work from Balna culvert to Sirauli culvert.
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Kamlesh s/o Jugnu 0 13
2. Rambahadur s/o Ramdayal 0 13
3. Nanhake s/o Ramdayal 5 13
4. Lalji s/o Mitan 5 13
5. Atul s/o Nanhe 0 13
6. Munnilal s/o Sri Kishan 3 13
7. Mahesh s/o Bhanu 5 13
8. Shri Kishan s/o Bandi 3 13
9. Jhabban s/o Ganeshi 4 13
10. Chandrapal s/o Babu 5 13
11. Changa s/o Ganeshi 3 13
12. Ramai s/o Lalta 5 13
13. Kunwar s/o Ganeshi 0 13
14. Deviprasad s/o Udda 0 13
15. Puran s/o Sukuru 0 13
16. Ramavtar s/o Guru 0 13
17. Gende s/o Horilal 10 13
18. Chandrapal s/o Babu 0 13
19. Sarvesh s/o Bhagwati 0 13
20. Kamlesh s/o Kalika 10 13
21. Kamlu s/o Gopali 10 13
22.
23. Gayari s/o Birju 10 13
24. Shivprasad s/o Chetram 10 13
25. Rampal s/o Sukuru 1 13
26. Manoj s/o Maniram 10 13
27. Jagrup s/o Diggaj 0 13
28. Mahendra s/o Ghaseete 8 13
29. Mangu s/o Natha 10 13
30. Kamlesh s/o Banke 0 13
31. Sheetlu s/o Dwarika 9 13
32. Guddu s/o Mohkam 10 13
33. Chetram s/o Horilal 10 13
34. Vishnu s/o Tilak 10 13
35. Shailendra s/o Shivlal 10 13
36. Gayaram s/o Kalika 10 13
37. Radhe s/o Prabhu 10 13
38. Ramdevi s/o Hans 10 13
39. Amber s/o Mohkam 10 13
40. Shravan s/o Jakhu 0 13 Lives in
41. Guddu s/o Cheda 10 13
42. Nanhe s/o Ramlal 10 13
43. Shivkumar s/o Bandi 5 13
44. Raju s/o Natha 10 13
45. Ramsingh s/o Basant 0 13
46. Naresh s/o Surajbali 4 13
47. Sunderlal s/o Chote 10 13
48. Jagdish s/o Nanha 10 13
49. Guru s/o Maiku 10 13
50. Guddu s/o Babu 0 13
51. Kesar s/o Diggaj 10 13
52. Madhav s/o Jakhru 10 13
53. Ramkhelawan s/o Bhagwati 0 13
54. Mahdeen s/o Rupan 10 13
55. Brij Bhushan s/o Chetram 10 13
56. Satish Kumar s/o Inder 10 13
Name of work: Brick road from Gopali’s house to Mahavir’s house.
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Kamlu s/o Gopali 5 7
2. Jagrup s/o Diggaj 5 7
3. Mayaram s/o Kalika 5 7
4. Munni s/o Buddha 0 7
5. Guddu s/o Chedda 5 7
6. Radheylal s/o Prabhu 4 7
7. Satiprasad s/o Indal 5 7
29. Village Panchyat Samodha. All muster rolls were not made available. The muster roll for a pond digging work was not made available at all. Husband of the Gram Pradhan runs the show here. The payments of wages is done not at work site but at Gram Pradhan’s house.
Name of work: Brick road from the house of Dilla Gaddi to the house Babu Gaddi.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on Muster Roll Comments
1. Siya Ram s/o Ram Swaroop 0 3
2. Gauri Shankar s/o Munni Lal 4 5
3. Ram Bilas s/o Munni Lal 3 4
4. Saddique Ali s/o Ali Mohammad 8 11
5. Sri Kishan s/o Mahadeen 4 5
6. Chote Lal s/o Ram Asre 5 7
7. Moti Lal s/o Ram Kishun 5 7
8. Shakeel s/o Zakir 4 6
9. Sripal s/o Bihari 5 7
10. Birender s/o Babu 2 4
11. Suresh s/o Ram Bharose 3 5
12. Munagu s/o Shiv Ratan 5 7
13. Islam s/o Jabir 5 7
14. Shravan Kumar s/o Bansi Lal 4 7
Name of work: Road from the field of Babu Pasi to the field of Ramesh Maurya.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on Muster Roll Comments
1. Juggi Lal s/o Gayari 8 14
2. Siya Ram s/o Ram Swaroop 8 13
3. Govind s/o Nanhu 8 14
4. Lalta s/o Sobaran 0 12
5. Inderpal s/o Nanku 8 12
6. Sita Ram s/o Sukh Lal 9 14
7. Ram Khilavan s/o Munni Lal 4 12
8. Daya Ram s/o Makhan 6 14
9. Saddique Ali s/o Ali Mohammad 10 13
10. Ranjeet s/o Ram Sewak 5 14
11. Sri Krishan s/o Mahadeen 8 14
12. Ram Lakhan s/o Dulari 7 14
13. Raj Kumar s/o Rameshwar 0 4
14. Chandrika s/o Gurudeen 6 13
15. Ram Gulam s/o Sukhlal 7 12
16. Beche Lal s/o Shyamu 9 13
17. Munagu s/o Shiv Ratan 8 14
18. Kamta s/o Anantu 8 14
19. Chatarpal s/o Chote Lal 9 14
20. Sone Lal s/o Bechu Lal 6 14
21. Telpal s/o Mahaveer 0 2
22. Shakir Ali s/o Malangu 8 14
23. Ramu s/o Rajaram 8 12
24. Pachcha s/o Fakire 6 12
25. Lalla s/o Becha 6 14
26. Anees s/o Siddiqui 8 14
27. Prem s/o Bachchu Lal 8 14
28. Narayan s/o Hari 9 13
29. Ikrar s/o Shamsher 6 14
30. Bhai Lal s/o Ramdeen 8 12
31. Sant Ram s/o Sundram 8 12
32. Hasmat Ali s/o Ali Sher 7 12
33. Kripali s/o Rajaram 5 11
34. Mansa Ram s/o Kishenu 7 11
35.
36. Mohur Ali s/o Sabir Ali 8 14
30. Village Panchayat Sarehari.
Name of work: Brick road from the house of Gaya Prasad to the corner of Shambhu’s house.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Rajaram s/o Shankar 4 7
2. Sudheer s/o Sant Ram 3 7
3. Mukesh s/o Shiv Dayal 3 7
4. Ajay Kumar s/o Putti Lal 5 7
31. Village Panchayat Serwe. 200 m. long link road was constructed out of which 80 m. has been damaged because of dispute. The width shown in records is more than actual. The Gram Pradhan has given Job Cards to his favourite people and genuine job seekers have been denied Job Cards. Therefore, true demand for work cannot be assessed. On an average only 3.9 days of work has been given to people who have been issued Job Cards. Out of about 700 person days of work the share of women and physically and mentally challenged is zero.
32. Village Panchayat Shahpur Chamraha.
Name of work: Drain desilting from Danna Kheda pond to Sai river.
S.N. Name of villager No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Naresh s/o Ram Swaroop 5 16 Sign on MR fake.
2. Anil s/o Raghuvande 5 13 ,,
3. Mahendra s/o Jagatpal 7 16
4. Kallu s/o Mohan Lal 8 16
5. Gayari s/o Parmeshwar 3 16
6. Suresh s/o Beche Lal 12 16
7. Mahendra s/o Mohan 12 16
8. Mayaram s/o Ghasi 5 16
33. Village Panchayat Sidhwal Malihabad. Gram Pradhan Sarnam confessed that in the road construction work between Natwar Baba and Sidhwal Malihabad he had saved Rs. 3000 out of which he shared Rs. 1600 with the officials. He said that for 9 years he had provided his tractor free of charge to villagers and for the last 3 years his Bolero vehicle in order to win the election. Now he was reaping the benefits of his investment. Sushila Devi, physically challenged daughter of Dwarika Prasad, was denied work by the Pradhan saying that he didn’t have any work to offer for her. In this village panchayat Job Cards have been issued to Ram Chandra s/o Beche Lal as well as Beche Lal s/o Maiku, whereas the age of Ram Chandra has been shown as 35 years and Beche Lal as 48 years. The difference between the ages of father and son is merely 13 years.
S. N Name of villagers No. of actual days No. of days on MR Comments
1. Guddu s/o Noor Mohammad 23 JC with Gram Pradhan.
2. Ram Krishna s/o Chedalal No other family member’s name on JC.
3. Horilal s/o Bihari 5 9 JC with Gram Pradhan
4. Munshilal s/o Lakshman 17 23 Photo on JC with own money
5. Ram Babu s/o Ganga Prasad 11 Photo on JC with own money
6. Ghura s/o Cheda 11 9 days’ work shown on JC
7. Dala s/o Ram Charan 10 JC with Gram Pradhan
8. Rajkumar s/o Maiku 11
9. Ghanshyam s/o Maiku 15 JC with Gram Pradhan
10. Pallu s/o Dayaram 3 Was not allowed to work on fourth day.
12. Vinod s/o Tikaram 40 Photo on JC with own money.
13. Sarwar s/o Abbas 14 26 JC with Gram Pradhan.
34. Village Panchayat Sirauli. The Gram Pradhan Ram Asre Dixit has given a written statement that he was not given any money to meet the expenses for photographs of workers to be affixed on the Job Cards, hence workers had to spend their own money for this purpose.
Jagdish Verma, Ram Sagar Verma, Neelkamal, Keshav Chand, Jaishankar, Ram Bharose, Bhagwandeen, Chandralekha, Suman Gautam, Rambabu, Gayadeen Bharti, Ashok Bharti, Yeshwant Rao, Virendra Singh, Karan Singh, Jitendra Dixit, Srinivas, Ram Naresh, Kamal Kishore, Vinay Kumar, Mahendra Yadav, Chunni Lal, Manoj, Ajay Patel, Usha, Mahesh, Arundhati Dhuru, Sandeep
Asha Parivar
A-893, Indira Nagar, Lucknow-226016
Ph: 0522 2347365, M: 9415022772, e-mail: ashaashram@yahoo.com
